When we finally learned the identity of Deep Throat in the summer of 2005, interest in the Watergate scandal went through a quick resurgence. Given all the problems experienced by presidents since Nixon, it can be easy to forget what a big deal Watergate was, so it’s interesting to watch the 1976 film adaptation of All the President’s Men for a primer in the subject.

On the evening of June 17 1972, burglars break into the Democratic National Committee offices in the Watergate Hotel. The police apprehend them and the Washington Post sends reporter Bob Woodward (Robert Redford) to cover the story. Fellow journalist Carl Bernstein (Dustin Hoffman) smells fresh ink as well, so he horns his way in to the situation. At the arraignment, Woodward learns that these are no ordinary crooks, as they have unusually sophisticated backgrounds. They also receive support from high places.

Woodward and Bernstein get stuck together to investigate, and what they find slowly unravels to become more and more intriguing. The film follows their path as they dig deeper into the events and find additional links within the White House.

That’s a simple plot synopsis for a complicated film. To its credit, Men takes a convoluted situation with scads of parties involved and makes it clear. This story easily could have turned confusing, but the movie manages to ensure that we always clearly understand what’s happening despite all the characters and situations.

It helps that Men features a wonderfully cool, understated tone. Even with all the drama onscreen, it avoids the expected melodrama and theatrics. We get a natural “fly on the wall” feeling here, as the film takes on a helpful documentary style. Crisp and subtle, the story unfolds in concise manner.

Although Men features a limited roster of settings, it never becomes weighed down in visual tedium. Face it – this is a movie packed with meetings and phone conversations. Director Alan J. Pakula doesn’t attempt to make these wild or stimulating, and that’s a good thing. Showy stabs at visual flair would seem out of place, so his choice to let the material carry the day is a good one.

Much credit for the film’s success has to go to the excellent cast as well. Redford and Hoffman excel as the leads. Their relationship grows gradually as they get used to each other and start to rub off on each other. There’s no massive bonding here, and they don’t turn into best buddies by the end. Instead, we see a believable sense of respect that emerges via the naturalistic, minimal performances. The actors lack excess emotion or theatrics and instead pull off their roles from the inside.

Tight and intelligent, All the President’s Men really is a film I find it hard to imagine could be made today – or at least made this well. It can be a product of its paranoid times, but that benefits the movie, as it fits the story. This is a concise, involving tale.

All the President’s Men appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 on this Blu-ray Disc. For the most part, the image held up well.

Sharpness was pretty positive. Occasionally the movie looked a bit soft and tentative, but it usually depicted good definition. Though the source photography limited delineation, the majority of the flick came across as reasonably concise and accurate. No issues with jagged edges and shimmering occurred, and I noticed no edge enhancement. As for source flaws, a couple specks appeared, but the movie otherwise seemed clean.

I didn’t expect a vivid palette from Men, but the colors seemed fine. They stayed somewhat cold and clinical, a tone that made sense for a serious, no-nonsense movie. The hues weren’t dynamic but they seemed to represent the original image.

Blacks were reasonably tight and firm. Low-light shots occasionally appeared a bit dense, but they seemed acceptably smooth and visible. This was a good-looking image given the problems with the original photography.

The film’s monaural soundtrack worked fine for the material. Dialogue was a bit thin but was clear and intelligible, and I didn’t notice any edginess. Effects were a minor concern in this chatty film. In fact, I find it hard to recall anything more than general ambience. These elements were lackluster but perfectly acceptable given the track’s vintage.

Men also featured very little score. Those elements seemed fine when they appeared. The music was never dynamic, but it appeared reasonably full and clear. Nothing here excelled, but the audio was more than adequate for a super-chatty movie.

How did the 2013 Blu-ray compare to those of the prior Blu-ray from 2011? Both are identical – literally. The 2013 release simply pairs the 2011 disc with a second platter that includes a new documentary.

That means all the 2011 Blu-ray’s extras repeat here, and on Disc One, the main attraction comes from an audio commentary with actor/producer Robert Redford. He provides a running, screen-specific chat. I can attach only one negative to this discussion: dead air. Redford leaves more than a few gaps during the piece. Otherwise, he gives us a lot to like.

Redford covers a broad mix of subjects. He talks about cast, characters and performances, interacting with Dustin Hoffman and improvisation, the genesis of his interest in the story, sets, locations and shooting in Washington, impressions of the real-life participants, and various production issues like cinematography and the lack of score.

Redford digs into these topics well. He offers good insight and detail as he goes through them. I especially like his comments about the way his work on The Candidate led to his interest in Watergate. Again, the dead air gets a little annoying, but the level of material makes this a winning and informative commentary.

After this we find a modern documentary called Telling the Truth About Lies: The Making of All the President’s Men. The 28-minute and 22-second piece mixes movie shots, archival materials, and interviews. We find notes from Redford, screenwriter William Goldman, authors Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, former executive editor of the Washington Post Ben Bradlee, cinematographer Gordon Willis, and actors Dustin Hoffman and Jane Alexander.

The show looks at Redford’s initial interest in the project and its development, the interaction between Hollywood and the real participants, the adaptation of the story and attempts to retain truthfulness, casting and performances, finding a director and his work, cinematography and lighting, sets meant to recreate the Post, and the movie’s impact.

Inevitably, a little of Redford’s commentary repeats here. However, this doesn’t happen much, so “Lies” offers a lot of fresh information. I particularly like the notes about the interaction among the actors as well as Willis’s work. This isn’t an extraordinary documentary, but it becomes efficient and informative.

We follow this with three featurettes. Woodward and Bernstein: Lighting the Fire runs 17 minutes, 54 seconds as it presents notes from Woodward, Bernstein, Bradlee, Redford, reporter Greg Krikorian, journalist Linda Ellerbee, former CBS anchorman Walter Cronkite, Center for Media and Public Affairs media director Matthew Felling, author Peter Schweizer, director Oliver Stone, and Newsweek senior editor Jonathan Alter. It covers the impact Woodward and Bernstein had on journalism as well as what’s happened in the field over the last 30 years. The program gets a little smoochy at times as we hear praise for “Woodstein”, but since much of it’s deserved, I won’t complain. We find a decent examination of journalism and the challenges its faces in this intriguing piece.

Next we get a featurette titled Out of the Shadows: The Man Who Was Deep Throat. This 16-minute and 21-second piece features Woodward, Goldman, Bernstein, Ellerbee, Stone, Bradlee, Schweizer, Alter, Krikorian, Felling, Cronkite, and former Watergate prosecutor Richard Ben-Veniste. The program covers the fascination with the identity of Deep Throat and lets us know biographical info about Mark Felt, the guy who was DT. We also hear about Woodward’s relationship with him, Felt’s motives and thoughts about other options he might have had, and issues related to anonymous sources.

I’d have liked more direct info about Felt here, but I think “Shadows” remains intelligent and compelling. It offers enough biographical data to suffice and digs into rich issues like ethics and motives. This makes it worthwhile and interesting.

For the final featurette, we discover a vintage program. Created for the movie’s original release, Pressure and the Press: The Making of All the President’s Men goes for 10 minutes, five seconds. It features Redford, Bernstein, Woodward, Hoffman, Bradlee, and director Alan J. Pakula.

Although I expected a cheesy puff piece, “Press” actually is quite good. It focuses mostly on some details of the facts behind the film, though we do get notes about photography and adaptation. It’s a surprisingly meaty little show, and the shots from the set are nice. This one’s an unexpected winner.

In addition to the film’s trailer, wee get a snippet from a 5/27/1976 episode of Dinah! with Jason Robards. It runs seven minutes and 10 seconds as Dinah Shore chats with actor Robards about the film. While it’s nice to see Robards here, the clip is little more than fluff. We get some minor insights into Robards’ interactions with Bradlee, but we don’t really learn much. However, I will admit I would love to know Dinah’s choice for the identity of Deep Throat; she claims she’s sure she knows, but she never tells us her pick.

Over on Disc Two, we get the set’s sole new extra: a 2013 documentary entitled All the President’s Men Revisited. In this one-hour, 27-minute, 46 second program, we hear from Redford, Bernstein, Bradlee, Woodward, Hoffman, former NBC news anchor Tom Brokaw, news show host Rachel Maddow, former Congressman Joe Scarborough, The Daily Show’s Jon Stewart, political commentator James Carville, New York Times executive editor Jill Abramson, Nixon Deputy Assistants Alexander Butterfield and Egil “Bud” Krogh, Nixon White House counsel John Dean, Committee to Re-elect the President treasurer Hugh Sloan, Nixon speechwriter Ben Stein, political commentator Mary Matalin, Mark Felt’s daughter Joan, Senate Watergate Committee member Fred Thompson, Watergate prosecutor Jill Wine-Banks, Deputy Attorney General William Ruckelshaus, House Judiciary Committee member Elizabeth Holtzman, ProPublica editor-in-chief Stephen Engelberg, journalist David Carr, TV journalist Sir David Frost and former Washington Post executive editor Marcus Brauchli.

“Revisited” mixes notes about the progress of the Watergate scandal as well as the Woodward/Bernstein investigation and the creation of the movie. However, it focuses most heavily on Watergate itself, so the issues connected to the hunt take a backseat.

Which is fine, as those areas get covered elsewhere on the disc. “Revisited” comes with a good array of folks who were involved back in the 1970s and covers the subjects pretty well. This isn’t an exhaustive program, of course, but it’s enjoyable and informative.

Understated but still dynamic, All the President’s Men holds up well after three decades. The movie benefits from its subtle tone and focuses on the story instead of melodrama or silliness. The Blu-ray offers relatively good picture, acceptable audio and some informative supplements. This is a solid version of the film, though it doesn’t add much for fans who already own the 2011 Blu-ray.

To rate this film visit the Widescreen Edition review of ALL THE PRESIDENT'S MEN