A Christmas Story appears in both an aspect ratio of approximately 1.85:1 and in a fullscreen version on this single-sided, double-layered DVD; the widescreen image has been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. Only the letterboxed picture was reviewed for this article. The movie seemed watchable but not much better in this erratic transfer.
For the most part, sharpness appeared satisfactory. The film came across as somewhat fuzzy and ill defined on occasion, though. While most of the flick was reasonably accurate and concise, it seemed a little tentative at times. I saw no issues with jagged edges or edge enhancement, but a little shimmering showed up periodically, mostly due to the fishnet stockings on the lamp. Print flaws caused more noticeable problems. The image seemed moderately grainy at times, and a mix of specks, spots and small marks popped up moderately frequently throughout the movie. A wee hair or two also materialized. None of these defects became overwhelming, but they were there much of the time.
Colors varied. Exteriors mostly looked pretty accurate and well defined, but the tones often came across as somewhat flat and lackluster. Some of that seemed to result from the film’s intentional subdued palette, but since the intensity of the hues varied for no apparent thematic reasons, I couldn’t chalk up the occasionally drab colors for stylistic reasons. (Undoubtedly, the film stocks of the era contributed as well.) Black levels tended to be reasonably dense but slightly on the inky side, and shadows were a bit thick and dull. The image of A Christmas Story didn’t do much that seemed particularly wrong, but it also rarely presented a picture that stood out as very positive.
Similar sentiments greeted the monaural soundtrack of A Christmas Story. During the film’s first third or so, speech usually seemed rather edgy. However, dialogue cleaned up considerably as the movie progressed. As such, lines from the flick’s last hour sounded a bit flat but were significantly stronger than those from earlier scenes. Effects also demonstrated distortion at times, particularly during the fantasy sequence with Ralph’s BB gun. Otherwise those elements seemed lackluster but acceptably accurate and clean. Music didn’t present much range, though some decent dynamics occasionally appeared. Still, the score failed to present any real problems, and it sounded fairly clear and bright. Ultimately, the audio of A Christmas Story seemed very average for its era.
How did the picture and audio of this “Ultimate Collector’s Edition” compare to those of the 2003 Special Edition? They’re literally identical, as the UCE simply repackages the 2003 set along with some non-disc-based supplements.
So that means no new extras on the DVDs themselves. In addition to the film’s theatrical trailer, DVD One houses an audio commentary from director/co-writer Bob Clark and actor Peter Billingsley. (The DVD’s case incorrectly lists actor Melinda Dillon as a participant, but she doesn’t appear.) Both men sit together for this running, screen-specific piece. While the pair offer some nice remembrances, this ultimately becomes a pretty average track.
Clark and Billingsley touch on a decent variety of topics. We learn about the different sources of the story and how Clark brought it to the screen. They discuss locations and production challenges as well as the prickliness of author Jean Shepherd. We also get a nice mix of interesting anecdotes from the set plus some discussion of the film’s initial reception and subsequent life. Clark seems really bitter about the many criticisms leveled at Porky’s over the years and appears happy to point out that Story might not exist without his earlier success with the sex comedy. We even find out which major actor almost got cast as the Old Man. Unfortunately, the guys often do little more than just talk about what they like, and more than a few empty spots appear. I learned some intriguing bits from this track – who knew Clark shot a sequel? – but it’s a spotty commentary as a whole.
On DVD Two, we open with Another Christmas Story, an 18-minute and 15-second retrospective. It mixes movie snippets and interviews with director Bob Clark plus actors Peter Billingsley, R.D. Robb, Scott Schwartz, and Zack Ward. They tell us continued reactions from the public toward the film, their own Christmas memories, and a number of anecdotes from the shoot. The program doesn’t remotely attempt to present a full examination of the film’s creation, but it includes some good notes and seems generally interesting.
A trivia contest pops up via Triple Dog Dare. Hosted by Peter Billingsley, we get a few questions about the movie. Based on your answers, you’ll also find short appearances from actors Zack Ward and Scott Schwartz and director Bob Clark. It’s generally pretty easy, though a couple of the toughest questions required educated guesses. Unfortunately, no reward comes with successful completion.
If you select Radio, we get a couple of stories told be Jean Shepherd. Part of his old radio show, we hear the tales that inspired the movie’s segments about Flick’s tongue and the pole plus his pursuit of the BB gun. It’s a lot of fun to check out these stories in their full versions as told by Shepherd.
Another contest shows up in Decoder. This requires you to match quotes with photos from those scenes. Get them correct and you’ll find some short remarks from a few of the actors. These are tongue in cheek, and the “Decoder” is only moderately entertaining.
The next featurette looks at the gun that remains the movie’s prized possession. Daisy Red Ryder: A History runs five minutes, 15 seconds. It launches with quick comments from Bob Clark and actors Schwartz, Robb, and Billingsley, but then we head to the Daisy factory to hear from co-curator of the Rogers Daisy Airgun Museum John Ford, customer service manager Orin Ribar, public relations manager Susan Gardner, and advertising manager Steven Ribar. We get notes about the history of the airgun, modifications made for the model used in the movie, and airgun safety issues. We also find out a little about the use of the gun on the set. No one ever does tell us if you can actually shoot out your eye with an airgun, but this is a reasonably efficient and interesting look at the subject.
Get a Leg Up finishes the DVD with an examination of the movie’s other most coveted item, the leg lamp. In this four-minute and 35-second featurette, we see DVD producer JM Kenny chat with lamp creator Joe Egeberg and tour the latter’s plant. We also hear from leg lamp manufacturer Dave Smith. I could live without Kenny’s snarky attitude, but it’s still kind of cool to learn that you can actually buy these things.
With that, we move to the supplements exclusive to this 2008 Ultimate Collector’s Edition.
We find a 48-Page Recipe Book that includes some movie info along with the expected cooking details. We learn how to make a variety of holiday-related items. It’s a nice little piece, even though I doubt I’ll ever make any of the recipes.
More cooking elements show up via five cookie cutters and a custom chef’s apron. The former allow you to make cookies shaped like some Christmas Story images such as the leg lamp, while the latter presents the film’s logo and a slogan. The DVD’s package also doubles as a cookie tin canister. All of these components are neat, though not exactly impressive.
While A Christmas Story made little box office impact in 1983, it found a huge audience via home video and cable broadcasts. The film deserves its positive reception, as it presents one of the better holiday flicks. It enjoys a wonderfully true to life feel and never indulges in the sappy sentimentality that mars most movies of this sort. The DVD offers average picture and sound plus a decent but unexceptional set of extras. The disc itself won’t impress anyone, but the movie itself is good enough to overcome any qualms I have about the package, so A Christmas Story merits my recommendation.
In its original Special Edition incarnation, at least. I kind of like this “Ultimate Collector’s Edition”, but I find it tough to advice fans to drop the extra bucks for it. The UCE runs about $13 more than the SE included here, so it’s not a ton of additional money, but I doubt most folks will be all that interested in the UCE’s exclusives. They’re fun for the devoted fan, but the majority of the audience will be happy with the standard Special Edition.
To rate this film, visit the Special Edition review of A CHRISTMAS STORY