DVD Movie Guide @ dvdmg.com
Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main


Paul Scheuring
Adrien Brody, Forest Whitaker, Cam Gigandet, Clifton Collins Jr., Ethan Cohn, Fisher Stevens, Travis Fimmel, David Banner
Writing Credits:
Paul Scheuring, Mario Giordano (novel, "Black Box"), Mario Giordano (film, "Das Experiment"), Christoph Darnstädt (film, "Das Experiment"), Don Bohlinger (film, "Das Experiment"), Oliver Hirschbiegel (film, "Das Experiment")

Everyone has a breaking point.

Oscar® winners Adrien Brody and Forest Whitaker star in this mind-shattering psychological thriller from the creator of TV’s Prison Break. Selected to participate in a two-week research project, a group of men agree to play inmates and guards in a simulation of life within a state prison. But as the 24 volunteers slip deeper into their roles, power corrupts, fears escalate and the experiment spins horribly out of control. Cam Gigandet, Clifton Collins Jr. and Maggie Grace co-star in this intensely shocking film.

Box Office:
$21.8 million.

Rated R

Aspect Ratio: 2.40:1
English DTS-HD MA 5.1
Supplements Subtitles:

Runtime: 96 min.
Price: $30.95
Release Date: 9/21/2010

• Previews


Panasonic 50" TH-50PZ77U 1080p Plasma Monitor; Sony STR-DG1200 7.1 Channel Receiver; Panasonic DMP-BD60K Blu-Ray Player using HDMI outputs; Michael Green Revolution Cinema 6i Speakers (all five); Kenwood 1050SW 150-watt Subwoofer.


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

The Experiment [Blu-Ray] (2010)

Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (September 10, 2010)

With two Oscar-winning actors in front of the camera and the producer of a successful TV series in the director’s chair, why did 2010’s The Experiment slip under the radar? Good question. No, neither Forest Whitaker nor Adrien Brody have become box office draws, but you’d still think a flick in which they star would at least elicit a theatrical run. Add to the Prison Break creator Paul T. Scheuring as director and the movie’s direct-to-video status becomes more perplexing.

And perversely makes Experiment more intriguing. When something with so many semi-high profile participants gets dumped onto video in this way, it leads to the assumption the movie must stink. The prospect that it’ll actually live up to its pedigree and offer a good experience is enough to entice me to screen it.

A remake of a 2001 German flick, Experiment introduces us to Travis Hunt (Brody), a part-time nursing home orderly who finds himself unemployed due to cutbacks. Without much on his plate – and with a jones to travel anyway – Travis decides to travel to India to be with a babe (Maggie Grace) he met at a peace rally.

But first he needs to money to get him there. He finds a behavioral experiment that will pay $1000 per day over a two-week period. With the promise of a $14,000 check for so little work, he signs up.

Travis and the others soon learn the nature of the experiment. They will be placed in a prison setting and split into “inmates” and “guards”. The lead scientist (Fisher Stevens) lays down some rules that must be followed; if violated, the experiment ends immediately and all involved lose their paydays.

As the experiment starts, most involved view it as a lark, but matters soon turn darker. In particular, a few of the guards take their roles very seriously, and Michael Barris (Whitaker) become their leader. This sets him against Travis, a pacifist who ends up as the de facto head of the prisoner.

As most psych students know, “The Milgram Experiment” explored the degree to which humans will follow orders. Intended in part to examine how so many people could do so many horrible things in Nazi Germany, the experiment showed that most folks will do what they’re told even under extreme circumstances. Though the participants believed they brought pain and perhaps even death to another “volunteer” – actually a confederate of the scientists – these people continued to obey commands.

I mention this because I suspect that if you question the believability of The Experiment with its creators, they would cite Milgram’s work as evidence of its plausibility. I don’t doubt that variations on the movie’s tale could be accurate, and that absolute power corrupts absolutely, so I don’t really question the film’s main thesis.

However, I do take issue with the contrived and illogical manner in which the flick explores its subjects. Too much of it makes little sense. Even though the guards understand that transgressions on their part will terminate the experiment – and zap their paychecks – they do it anyway. Granted, the movie does empower them when they get away with some incidents, but the abandon with which they risk the money makes no sense.

The work of the scientists also totally stretches credulity. All sorts of havoc occurs, and yet they do nothing to interfere. Where exactly do they plan to publish their findings? The session becomes so absurdly unethical so quickly that the results would be useless.

And why would they let all hell break loose when they must know they’ll be liable? Participants are severely injured and even killed, but the scientists do nothing. At its end, the movie does indicate that they’ll suffer repercussions, but that doesn’t explain why they’d put themselves out on that limb in the first place. All these issues mean that even if one swallows the concept that the “guards” would treat the “prisoners” so horribly, the movie still lacks a basic believability and logic.

Drop those concerns and the film doesn’t work much better, largely because it follows such stock characters. Travis is little more than a faux Jesus, while Barris suffers from feeble psychological background. We learn little about the various parts in terms of exposition, but we do see that Barris cares for his sick – and cruel and demeaning – mother.

That sets up the modest, shy Barris with Little Man Syndrome. Oh, he’s a big enough guy in terms of size, but we see he’s been made to feel small his whole life. When he gets a taste of power, he really likes it; in a tacky moment, we notice that Barris sports a post-violence erection. Whatever grasp on reality he held goes out the window as he embraces his newfound virility.

Yeep. Experiment boasts a whole array of thin characters like this who add no texture to the piece. I suspect we’re supposed to view Barris as an everyman sort to demonstrate how quickly any of us could go coo-coo for Cocoa Puffs, but that doesn’t work. Since we know that Barris suffered from abuse at the hands of his nasty momma and probably boasts a broad array of psychological issues, his transformation fails to feel universal. Barris rapidly goes from Unassuming Nice Guy With a Bad Wig to Grade A Nutbag, and it doesn’t make sense.

In reality, The Experiment exists as little more than a ham-fisted attempt at social commentary. Are many – most? all? – people capable of atrocities when placed in certain situations? Sure. Does this movie deliver any kind of thoughtful message? Nope. It exists as a sadistic fantasy wrapped in delusions of relevance.

The Blu-ray Grades: Picture B+/ Audio B/ Bonus D-

The Experiment appears in an aspect ratio of approximately 2.40:1 on this Blu-Ray Disc. Don’t expect problems from this solid transfer.

Very few issues with sharpness occurred. The film usually came across as crisp and well-defined. Wide shots occasionally looked a bit soft, but not to a significant degree. I saw no problems with jagged edges or shimmering, and edge enhancement was minor. Source flaws weren’t a concern, as none cropped up through the movie.

As one might expect given the genre, Experiment delivered a subdued palette. Blues dominated the proceedings, as other tones popped up infrequently; brighter hues tended to appear only when Travis fantasized about his trip to India. The colors looked good within the production design. Blacks always seemed deep and full, while shadows were mostly clean and smooth. The occasional interior shot was a little murky, but otherwise low-light elements seemed concise. Overall, the flick presented an attractive transfer.

Though not amazing, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack of Experiment worked well. The soundfield emphasized the forward channels and worked quite well within that realm. The front spectrum was nicely broad and blended together cleanly. The elements remained in the appropriate locations and panned smoothly across the channels

Surround usage tended toward general reinforcement and atmospherics, though the rear speakers came to life pretty well during action or surreal sequences. These channels didn’t dazzle, but they brought some life to the mix.

Audio quality always seemed good. Speech was consistently natural and crisp, with no signs of edginess. Music was clean and concise. The score appeared well-recorded and dynamic. Effects also came across as lively and distinctive, and they lacked distortion. Bass response was deep and firm. Overall, the audio was more than fine for the story.

An ad for Red Hill opens the disc. It also appears under Previews along with clips for 30 Days of Night: Dark Days, Game of Death, Harry Brown, The Secret in Their Eyes, and The Pillars of the Earth. No trailer for Experiment - or any other extras – show up here.

On the surface, The Experiment promises an intriguing, thought-provoking drama. Unfortunately, it suffers from too many stretches in logic and too many cheap attempts to deliver a “message”. The Blu-ray provides strong picture and very good audio but lacks notable supplements. Skip this tacky, unconvincing attempt at social commentary.

Viewer Film Ratings: 1.3333 Stars Number of Votes: 3
0 3:
View Averages for all rated titles.

Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main