DVD Movie Guide @ dvdmg.com
Review Archive:  # | A-C | D-F | G-I | J-L | M-O | P-R | S-U | V-Z | Viewer Ratings | Main


Geoff Dunbar
Paul McCartney
Writing Credits:

Enchanting Animated Tales with original Music by Paul McCartney.

Paul McCartney proudly presents a collection of award-winning animated films and soundtracks. "The ideas that turned me on as a kid are the same ones that fascinate me today. I don't know that we ever outgrow our passion for adventure, humor or romance. There's a childlike quality to the art of animation, and, married with a bit of music, it seemed the perfect way to bring these magical stories to life. I hope you enjoy watching them as much as I enjoyed making them."
- Paul McCartney

Rated NR

Widescreen 1.78:1/16x9
English Dolby Digital 5.1

Runtime: 43 min.
Price: $29.99
Release Date: 4/13/2004

• “Paul Talks About the Animation Collection”
• “The Making of Tropic Island Hum
• “The Making of Tuesday
Rupert and the Frog Song: Line Tests
Tropic Island Hum: Layouts, Storyboards and Line Tests
Tuesday: Line Tests and Storyboards
• Booklet


Sony 36" WEGA KV-36FS12 Monitor; Sony DA333ES Processor/Receiver; Panasonic CV-50 DVD Player using component outputs; Michael Green Revolution Cinema 6i Speakers (all five); Sony SA-WM40 Subwoofer.


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Paul McCartney: The Music and Animation Collection (2004)

Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (April 13, 2004)

Though he never went the same path as Elton John or Phil Collins and composed for a Disney flick, Paul McCartney still dabbled in animation over the years. On The Music and Animation Collection, we find a compilation of some of this work.

Three animated stories appear. We start with Tropic Island Hum, in which a hot-air balloon piloting toad named Froggo (voiced by McCartney) rescues Wirral the Squirrel (Macca again) as hunters try to kill the rodent. For safekeeping, Froggo flies Wirral to an island on which animals get protected from outside forces that mean to harm them. They dance and sing, and Wirral falls in love.

Next we find Tuesday. It shows life in a marsh when the frogs learn they can fly aboard their lily pads. They zoom around town, cause a little mischief and have some fun before daybreak comes and they lose their magical abilities.

Lastly, Rupert & the Frog Song shows a young suburban bear named Rupert (McCartney) who enjoys a nice day out in nature. He finds a secret frog society and sneaks into it. There he witnesses a special musical performance that occurs only once ever couple of centuries.

The best word to describe these shorts is “unassuming”. None of them attempt to provide anything grand or broad. They provide varying levels of cuteness along with a little music. No one will feel threatened over at Disney. No one will confuse the music for McCartney’s best work, either, as the tunes seem slight and unmemorable.

Nonetheless, some moderately enjoyable work appears here. “Hum” feels like the weakest link. It suffers from a preachy attitude; many of us already know McCartney’s passion about animal rights, and some of us share the sentiment. Nonetheless, “Hum” pounds us a little too heavily with his opinions. It also fails to present any form of real story and seems like a trailer more than a full-length tale.

”Tuesday”, on the other hand, is a real charmer. Unlike “Hum”, it doesn’t include a McCartney tune; he composed the music and performed as a voice actor – along with Dustin Hoffman! – but didn’t toss in a song. The short benefits from the absence of a production number, as it works because of its mute simplicity. We simply watch the frogs fly around and enjoy their quiet antics. It’s low-key and lightly elegant and provides a winning cartoon.

”Rupert” fell somewhere in between those two. It had some charming moments and presented more personality than the banal “Hum”, but it also seemed like little more than an excuse for a musical number. This one worked pretty well, especially since some of the animation got fairly abstract during “We All Stand Together”. Nonetheless, the short failed to excel, and “Tuesday” remained the best of the bunch.

The DVD Grades: Picture B-/ Audio A-/ Bonus B-

Paul McCartney: The Music and Animation Collection appears in an aspect ratio of 1.78:1 on this single-sided, double-layered DVD; the image has been enhanced for 16X9 televisions. The shorts looked decent but not great.

Sharpness presented a moderate concern. The movie usually looked acceptably accurate and well defined, but it also showed a few soft shots. Wide images demonstrated the least detailed images; they never became terribly fuzzy, but they lacked crispness. The film took on a moderately gauzy look at times. No problems with jagged edges or moiré effects occurred, and I detected no signs of edge enhancement. Print flaws stayed modest but seemed a little more substantial than I expected. Occasional examples of grit and specks popped up at times.

Colors varied but appeared fairly decent. Even in the tropical settings, the tones never became terribly vivid and lively. Still, they remained generally concise and well rendered; they just failed to become better than that. Blacks appeared acceptably dense and dark, and shadows were reasonably detailed and firm. The image of Collection never seemed bad, but it didn’t do much that appeared terrific either.

On the other hand, the Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack of the McCartney Music and Animation Collection firmly exceeded my expectations. The soundfield seemed very active and provided a really lively experience. Music mostly remained in the front, where it presented good stereo imaging. However, the score and songs also spread nicely to the rear for reinforcement.

As for effects, they featured prominently in all three stories. The different elements popped up all around the five speakers and added a lot of life to the presentation. From flying frogs to shooting guns, the various bits came from appropriate places and moved smoothly around the room.

Audio quality also seemed strong. Speech consistently sounded natural and distinctive, with no intelligibility issues or edginess. Music was lush and lively, and the songs showed fine dynamics. Bass response seemed terrific across the board; whether for effects or music, low-end appeared tight and warm. Effects sounded clean and accurate and suffered from no distortion. Overall, the audio of Collection really impressed me, as it was both enveloping and crisp.

A mix of extras pop up on this DVD. We start with Paul Talks About the Animation Collection. In this six-minute and 58-second featurette, McCartney discusses his initial interest in “Rupert” and his involvement in the cartoon, the use of cel and CG animation, his interest in “Tuesday” and work on it, his general attitude toward the shorts, his voice work, and his plans for future animated films. It’s fun to hear Macca chat about the subject, especially since he remains enthusiastic; Paul can often be on cruise control in interviews, so it’s quite interesting to listen to him go over an unusual subject with some zeal. This featurette proves useful and enjoyable.

Next we get The Making of Tropic Island Hum. In this 12-minute and three-second piece, we find a mix of movie snippets, behind the scenes bits, and interviews. We hear from director Geoff Dunbar and unnamed animators. They chat about the origins of the film and characters, and developing the animation. The program seems simple but informative. It covers the various topics reasonably well, and the shots from behind the scenes add some good elements. Make sure you stick around to the end, as it finishes with shots of an animated Paul and Linda.

After this we find The Making of Tuesday. This one lasts 11 minutes, 57 seconds and follows the same format as the prior show. It includes comments from McCartney, though shots from behind the scenes dominate. We learn of Paul’s interest in the book, visual development, live action photography used as a visual aid for animators and other tools, various animation techniques, and recording the music. The main attraction here stems from all the behind the scenes video, especially since many of these involve McCartney heavily. It’s fun to see him work on the project, and those elements make the program quite involving.

In the next area, we find Rupert and the Frog Song Line Tests. This set runs 10 minutes, 50 seconds and essentially shows the entire short in unfinished form. We mostly see rough animation as it progresses. This seems like an interesting way to watch the evolution of the project.

Similar material appears in Tropic Island Hum: Layouts, Storyboards and Line Tests (11 minutes, 23 seconds) as well as Tuesday: Line Tests and Storyboards (20 minutes, 15 seconds). “Hum” works much like “Rupert” and mainly focuses on the rough animation. The first half of “Tuesday” functions the same way, but the second half gives us a surfeit of storyboards. We get a collection of filmed boards that follow the movie’s progress without auditory accompaniment. All of these domains offer fun glimpses of the various processes.

Some flicks present talking menus, particularly Disney ones that try to make the DVDs kid-friendly. However, none of the others include voice work from arguably the most famous rock star alive today. McCartney provides a DVD menu introduction with comments as himself and in character as Wirral. It’s a fun element.

Lastly, the package includes a small booklet. This presents notes about the three shorts and their characters. We also get information about McCartney and director Geoff Dunbar, lyrics to songs, and some photos and drawings. It offers a nice little piece.

Overall, the three shorts on Paul McCartney: The Music and Animation Collection provide a moderate amount of enjoyment. One seems terrific, another appears somewhat drab, and the third falls in the middle. The DVD features decent picture with surprisingly strong audio and a generally nice set of extras. With a list price of almost $30, the Collection comes at a steep cost; I’d more readily recommend it if it ran for $10 less. Still, I’m sure most McCartney fans will want to add this to their collections.

Viewer Film Ratings: 4.2857 Stars Number of Votes: 7
2 3:
View Averages for all rated titles.