Reviewed by Colin Jacobson (September 11, 2025)
A massive movie star through the 1930s, Greta Garbo concluded her career via 1941’s Two-Faced Woman. For her penultimate film, we go back two years earlier for 1939’s Ninotchka.
Soviet representatives Buljanoff (Felix Bressart), Iranoff (Sig Ruman) and Kopalski (Alexander Granach) come to Paris to sell jewels that belonged to the Grand Duchess Swana (Ina Claire). When she learns of this, she attempts to reclaim her property.
The Grand Duchess’s friend Count Léon d'Algout (Melvyn Douglas) manages to stall the sale and this brings stern Soviet envoy Nina Ivanovna "Ninotchka" Yakushova (Garbo) to settle the situation. Matters complicate when the no-nonsense Ninotchka finds herself romantically interested in the Count.
Back in 1939, they still nominated 10 movies for Best Picture, a practice that ended after the 1943 batch of films. Ninotchka became one of the 10 picks from 1939 and it lost to the legendary Gone With the Wind.
I can’t say the Academy denied Ninotchka a deserved Best Picture win. Even if one doesn’t think Gone With the Wind deserved the big prize – then called “Outstanding Production” – 1939 boasted so many classics like The Wizard of Oz, Stagecoach and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington that Ninotchka faced intense competition.
Still, Ninotchka does provide an unusually good romantic comedy, and I might feel Garbo merited the Best Actress trophy. She lost to Vivian Leigh’s work in Wind but I could make a strong case that Garbo deserved the prize instead.
Known for her somber and serious style, Garbo tried to alter that trend and come across as more frivolous and “American” with Two-Faced Woman. This didn’t go over well and the movie’s reception apparently stung Garbo.
Despite her reputation as dark and dramatic, Ninotchka shows Garbo’s comedic talents – within her established cinematic persona, that is. Indeed, Garbo shows a delightful willingness to self-parody as our title character.
Much of the film’s humor stems from its understanding that viewers would come to Ninotchka with a certain idea of what to expect from Garbo. It toys with these in a number of ways such us a couple scenes in which it reminds us of her most famous piece of dialogue: “I want to be alone”.
In other hands, these bits of self-reference could create eye-rolling, but Garbo’s deadpan approach to the part makes the jokes work. She refuses to break character and that means her performance becomes all the more effective.
Ninotchka does change and loosen up as the movie progresses. Garbo allows these developments to feel natural and logical.
Garbo enjoys good chemistry with Douglas as well. The film posits them as the usual opposites who attract and they pull off this potentially trite theme.
A taut script from Charles Brackett, Billy Wilder and Walter Reisch helps matters. The screenplay manages plenty of funny lines and a good narrative progression as well.
If forced to select an issue with Ninotchka, I’d say 111 minutes probably makes it a little long for its fairly simple plot. Nonetheless, the end result comes with more than enough cleverness and charm to allow me to ignore that “flaw” and enjoy this vivid rom-com.