I saw no signs with jagged edges or moiré effects, and edge haloes remained absent. I also witnessed no issues with print flaws, as this was a consistently clean image, and grain seemed reasonable. Blacks looked deep and rich, while low-light shots came across as smooth and distinctive. Whites and contrast got a boost from HDR. Enough of the image appeared strong enough to make this a "B" presentation, but I wish the palette didn't seem so off.
At least the DTS-HD MA 5.1 worked well for the most part. Adapted from the original Dolby Surround mix – which also appeared on the disc – the 5.1 track used the various channels in a positive manner.
The soundscape didn’t go overboard, but it filled the room with logical audio that blended together in a smooth, satisfying manner. This became most apparent in action scenes or those with rain/thunder, but even in quieter sequences, the track created a solid sense of place.
Audio quality held up well after 48 years. Music was rich and full, and speech usually sounded fine. Some of the lines could seem a bit brittle or edgy, but they mostly came across with positive delineation.
Effects appeared accurate and lively, with clean highs and impressive low-end when necessary. These came with a price, however, as it seemed obvious some of the elements emanated from more modern recordings and not the 1977 stems. If one can ignore that, though, the 5.1 track satisfied.
Speaking of the 1977 audio, the Blu-ray also included that original DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix. It offered a less active soundfield compared to the 5.1 version.
However, this didn’t make the track timid, as it formed a nice sense of space and place. It also fit together naturally, even if it didn’t use the back channels as actively as its 5.1 partner.
Without those re-recorded effects, I felt the 2.0 audio blended sonically in a more pleasing manner. The recordings simply connected together better, as I didn’t get any jarring disconnect between 1977 elements and newer material.
This meant I liked the 2.0 mix more than the 5.1 presentation. While the latter worked fine, I thought the 2.0 seemed like a superior fit for the movie.
How did the 4K UHD compare to the simultaneously released Criterion Blu-ray? Both came with identical audio options.
The Dolby Vision UHD offered obviously superior definition and blacks when compared to the BD, and it also toned down the green colors. Those looked more extreme than they did on the UHD, which came as a surprise given that HDR normally accentuates hues.
All of this made the UHD a definite upgrade over the super-green BD. Still, a 4K UHD version of the film with the original color palette would've reached "A" territory.
All the set's extras appear on a separate Blu-ray disc. Friedkin Uncut brings a 2018 documentary that runs one hour, 47 minutes, 26 seconds. It provides notes from director William Friedkin, filmmakers Francis Ford Coppola, Quentin Tarantino, Wes Anderson, Walter Hill, Philip Kaufman, Edgar Wright, Dario Argento, and Damien Chazelle, screenwriter Walon Green, NYPD homicide detective/technical advisor Randy Jurgensen, writer/film scholar Antonio Monda, conductors Gianandrea Noseda and Zubin Mehta, director of photography Caleb Deschanel, film critic Simon Blumenfeld, and actors Ellen Burstyn, Juno Temple, William Petersen, Willem Dafoe, Gina Gershon, Matthew McConaughey, and Michael Shannon.
After an introduction that looks at some of Friedkin's philosophies as well as The Exorcist, "Uncut" goes back to Friedkin's early life. It then gets into his start in movies/TV and explores his career.
On the positive side, "Uncut" comes with lots of good notes. However, it follows a less than coherent structure that becomes a distraction, so it doesn't quite live up to its potential.
With James Gray and Sean Fennessey, we find a 28-minute, 18-second program. As implied by the title, it provides a conversation between filmmaker Gray and critic Fennessey.
They essentially offer an analysis and appreciation of Sorcerer. For the most part, it becomes an engaging discussion.
From 2015, another chat appears under William Friedkin and Nicholas Winding Refn. This one lasts one hour, 17 minutes, 23 seconds and pair the two filmmakers.
They look at elements related to Sorcerer such as its reception in 197 as well as aspects of its development and creation. It starts off in an annoyingly quirky manner but the chat soon becomes more substantial and informative, especially because Refn proves to become a challenging interviewer.
An audio-only compilation, Walon Green and Bud Smith occupies 36 minutes, 27 seconds. It features screenwriter Green and editor Bud Smith while interviewed by film scholar Giulia D'Agnolo Vallan for her 2003 Friedkin biography.
They discuss aspects of their careers as well as their work on Sorcerer. We find a good array of insights.
Behind the Scenes goes for six minutes, nine seconds and show silent footage of the shoot in New Jersey. The absence of audio makes it less valuable than one might prefer and the material comes with low quality - Super8, I'm guessing - but this still turns into a fun addition.
In addition to the film's trailer, we conclude with a booklet that provides credits, art and an essay from critic Justin Chang. It completes the set well.
A third platter provides the movie on a Blu-ray disc.
Though not a success when released in 1977, Sorcerer holds up well after the last 48 years. It brings us an intriguing and eventually dynamic thriller with a lot going for it. The 4K UHD offers good audio and supplements but alterations to the movie’s original palette makes it inconsistent in terms of visuals. While this Criterion release has a lot going for it, the changed colors make it more difficult for me to recommend.